
So, the test series is over and South Africa emerged victorious despite Kevin Pietersen’s England winning the final test match at The Oval. Overall, it was a deserved series win for Graeme Smith’s men. They have proved their worth as the second best team in the world and I for one can’t wait to see them take on Australia in December. It should be a thrilling contest and should give an indicator to England’s chances against Australia next summer. If the Proteas win this one, I might be tempted to stick some of my cricket betting money on England to regain The Ashes. However, that’s a debate for another day.
To summarise the series between England and South Africa, I thought the best thing to do was to give marks out of ten for each player as well as a brief summary of how they fared in the test matches. Today I will be looking at England and in my next piece for Deep Fine Leg, I shall be casting an eye over the victorious South Africans. So, here it goes….
Andrew Strauss - 6. This is a man who still has a lot to do to convince me he is the best partner for Alistair Cook at the top of the order. Scored just one fifty on his way to averaging 25.71. I imagine he will be on the plane to India, but he certainly isn’t the same player that burst onto the scene in 2004.
Alistair Cook - 7. I must admit that I find him rather frustrating. He strikes me as someone who is happy enough getting 60 odd to keep his average up. This is presumably not the case, but he has now gone 11 test match innings without a century. His average against South Africa was 47, which is satisfactory, but he needs more big scores. Failed to take a game by the scruff of the neck (like Marcus Trescothick used to) for a while now.
Michael Vaughan - 4. Not been the best series for the Yorkshire-man has it? Lose two test matches, score 40 runs at an average of 8 and resigned from the captaincy. Has been a superb captain though and for that all England fans are grateful. I hope to see him return to the side as the batsman we all know he can be.
Ian Bell - 6. Like Cook, Bell frustrates me a lot. He has a fantastic technique and should be playing more significant innings than he is. Apart from the 199 he scored in the first test match, there was only one other 50. That innings at Lords also soaked up well over half of his runs for the series. If he is to bat at number three, he must (again, like Cook) start to dominate opposition bowlers and playing match-winning innings for his side.

Kevin Pietersen -9. Not a lot can be said about KP that hasn’t already been expressed by every pundit across the country. He is, quite simply, the best batsman in the side and one of the best in the world. Averaged over 60 with the bat and deservedly picked up the man of the series award. This was topped off with a win and a century during his first test as captain. Let’s just hope the massive weight on his shoulders doesn’t hinder his batting or captaincy. He is the key man in England’s future.
Paul Collingwood - 7. Rescued his test match career with an excellent century at Edgbaston and this was followed up with a fifty and an unbeaten 20-odd at The Oval. After being dropped from the side for Headingley, he actually ended up with an impressive average of 58 for the series Now he has resigned from the one-day captaincy I expect his to have an excellent one-day series against South Africa.
Andrew Flintoff - 7. Like I have said before, it is great to have him back. His bowling gives England’s attack that extra piece of aggression and pace. His batting is no where near where it should be though and doesn’t suit batting at six at the minute. Luckily though, his bowling alone makes him one of Pietersen’s most important players.
Tim Ambrose - 4. Not exactly a thrilling series for the pint-sized glove man. Put down a couple of chances and this wasn’t rescued with a batting average of 16.16. He was crazily thrown in at number six at Headingley, which wasn’t his fault, but it proved that he simply isn’t good enough. Matt Prior or James Foster to be considered for India.
Stuart Broad - 7. The 22-year-old will be a huge part of England’s future. His bowling improved a lot in the final test as well and once he works out what type of bowler he is - he will take lots of wickets. Considering he averaged over 50 with the bat in this series, he could become England’s number one all-rounder.
Steve Harmison - 9. Only played the one test match, but boy didn’t he do well. Only took four wickets, but for the first time in the series the South African batsman were greeted with aggressive pace and bounce. The England attack looks so much stronger with an in-form Steve Harmison as part of it. The only question is, how long will he stay in form?
James Anderson - 8. I’m so pleased to see Jimmy cement his place in the side. Not only was he leading wicket taker with 15 victims, but his batting has improved and he has slowly become one of the best fielders in the side. The 26-year-old has replaced Matthew Hoggard as the swing minded opening bowler and hopefully he can continue his knack of taking crucial wickets throughout the winter.
Monty Panesar - 7. For my mind, it seems that he still isn’t quite convinced he belongs in test cricket. He needs to back his own ability a lot more. As has been well documented, he needs to learn to vary his deliveries to avoid becoming too predictable. Still, he took 13 wickets and remains a fans favourite.
Ryan Sidebottom - 6. He looked absolutely shattered against South Africa and will benefit from the rest he is currently getting. He will always try his best and provides the England attack with a bit of variety, but maybe he has had his year in the spotlight. It will be interesting to see how he fares this Winter against India and West Indies.
Darren Pattinson - 5. It wasn’t his fault that he was selected and it wasn’t his fault that England’s batsmen failed so miserably at Headingley. I’d happily stick all of my cricket betting money on him never playing for England again.
So, there we have it. Still a lot of work to be done by this England squad if they are to improve as a team. Question marks remain over the opening batsmen, the number six slot, the wicket-keeper, Andrew Flintoff’s role in the team, Stuart Broad’s bowling, Monty Panesar’s variation and Steve Harmison’s ability to tour successfully. It’s going to be an interesting few months before the big one next summer!
Thomas Rooney - Freelance Sports Journalist